Newsgroups: alt.paranet.ufo
From: kymhorsell@gmail.com
Subject: UFO's and lightning

[uploaded 54 times; last 28/09/2024]

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY:
- A recent article has raised questions about the connection between
  lightning and UFO sightings.
- We would expect there to be some connection with some types of UFO
  sightings but not all. Maybe not even most.  The AI s/w I'm
  developing picks Fireball and Sphere UFO types (as described by
  NUFORC reports) as the ones most connected with lightning strikes in
  the region during the same month.  But the connection is strong
  only in a few states. In several more it is weak. But in most states
  there seems to be no link.
- The AI further picks out those states showing a strong link (in UT
  it explains 90+% of Fireball and "orb" sightings) is via
  precipitation. States with low precip in Dec and Jan and also low
  variation in prec month to month are the states with a strong
  connection between lighting and Fireball UFO sightings.


I noticed a recent piece in The Debrief on the connection between
lightning, specifically ball lightning, and at least some of the
observed UFO activity. Certainly some of the YT vids showing orbs
floating down mountainsides does suggest something not under the same
kind of control as big dark pyramids tumbling around in the sky over
the Pentagon.

And many of us old enough will remember the relevant appendixes on the
Condon Report that linked some UFO reports with the enigmatic ball
lightning phenomenon, ironically itself having been viewed as a
fantasy only a matter of a couple decades before that Report came out.
One of the stories in the appendix in question related how a key
physicist was on a plane travelling to a conference to debunk the whole
idea of ball lightning when the plane he was travelling in was hit by
lightning and a fuzzy glowing ball proceeded to travel at least part
of the length of the isle. Sound of shredding paper.

And similar if not the same phenomena is where I started my current
exploration of UFO's with the "mountain lights" seen in parts of
Norway.  At the time I discovered the pattern of sightings had a very
strong climate link. As the years warmed the number of sightings were
predicted to grow less and less. And, surprise, I recently revisited
one website that had been promoting study of the lights to find it was
mostly abandoned with no-one answering emails; even college students
that had received degrees from projects related to recording the
sightings which apparently dropped to near 0 a few years back.

So it's worth trying to determine how many UFO sightings in N Am
"might" be related to lightning.

My database already has a large collection of datasets that relate to
US lightning storms. Over the past decades it seems such storms --
given commercial considerations -- have become an active area of
study and prediction.  So some numbers are now not available for free
download any more.  But the NOAA maintains a set of data that record daily
or monthly number of lightning strikes using several different types of
instruments.  E.g. a network of radio stations listens out for
lightning-generated static.  Even GPS satellites can detect lighting
strikes -- after a fashion -- in the territory they fly over. There
are other methods.

So we can use this data and use it to predict various "types" of UFO
sighting and try to determine which types of sighting are best
predicted by lightning activity, and how well.

I mostly use the NUFORC database and I do that here. These data
consist of details entered by observers via a web form. So all data is
probably questionable. :) Many sightings are entered years and sometimes
decades later, so expecting people to remember the date and time of a
signing from 10y ago is a tall order. In addition, the folks at NUFORC
also give each report a light once over and add in a couple
classification fields to each sighting. One is the "shape" field.
Oval, Triangle, Sphere, etc. are included in the list of shapes.  But
we can also search each sighting for keywords in the body of the text.
Appropriate to lightning or ball lightning is a keyword not included in
the official "shape" field -- the term "orb".

So we can go through each "type" of UFO sighting (incl the keyword "orb")
and decide in which states lightning seems to predict UFO activity of
that type within the state. We don't really expect lighting in Texas to
be correlated in some interesting way against the totality of US UFO
sightings within a given month. But it might be informative of the
strength of the link to compare lightning in TX against UFO sightings
in TX with the word "orb" in the report. &ct.

So we can run all these regression models -- throw away all the
results that are not statistically significant using 2
different tests (essentially we have to be 99% sure the result cant
just be due to some lucky pattern in the particular data we're using)
and we can count up for each UFO type how many states of the US see a
link between lighting and those kinds of UFO sightings. Order from
largest to least.

UFO type	Number of states that see
		a strong link between lightning strikes
		and UFO sightings within each month
Fireball	13
Light		13
Circle		11
Sphere		11
Unknown		8
Cigar		7
Formation	7
Oval		6
Triangle	6
Changing	5
Disk		5
Other		5
orb		5
Diamond		4
Cylinder	3
Rectangle	2
Teardrop	2
Cone		1
Cross		1
Flash		1
Chevron		0
Egg		0

The "types" that start with the capital letters are the official
NUFORC sighting classification terms. The "orb" is our addition to
count reports that contain that word as " orb " or " orbs " (note the spaces).

At the top of the list we see "Fireball" UFO's seem to fit the bill as
a phenomenon at least partly related to some king of unusual
lightning science. "Light" UFO's too. It seems in 13 states there are
strong connections between lighting and the relevant UFO sighting types.

It also turns out to be the case in "most" states there is absolutely
no connection between lighting and any kind of UFO sighting.  There
seems to be some other element that is key to whether or not the 2
align at least some of the time. I suspect at this point it is
"elevation". Maybe at higher altitudes there is a stronger connection
that at MSL. We'll look at that in the future, depending on what the
Big Report in June says about UFO's and humanity's status in the universe. :)

But one funny thing we might note. "Triangle" UFO's seem to be related
to lightning too. How can a triangle be mistaken for some blob of
light that was created by a lightning bolt?

A second funny thing which may be key -- the "orb" UFO type seems to
be much less related to lightning than some classic UFO shapes.  How
can this be? "Orb" was supposedly the normal way people that saw a
ball lightning or similar phenomena should describe what they saw.
Yet it isn't.

The solution is likely to be -- our idea that links how widespread
lighting/UFO links are by counting states is the wrong metric to
decide how strong the link is. We need a new measure.

So the next thing we might try is using the average "explanation
power" (R2) of the link in each state multiplied by the number of
states where the R2 is significantly positive. If the link is very
strong (R2 near 1) in a FEW states it is likely showing a stronger
association than a bunch of very small R2 over a larger number of states.

Plonking that metrics into out comparison program we get:

UFO type	#states * avg(R2) (== sum of R2s)
Fireball	3.85569
orb		3.20574
Sphere		3.17438
Diamond		2.32742
Cigar		2.28911
Circle		2.20659
Cylinder	1.97731
Changing	1.73072
Unknown		1.71972
Formation	1.46869
Light		1.44085
Other		1.24844
Oval		1.06086
Cone		0.874993
Cross		0.874185
Rectangle	0.842907
Disk		0.814893
Teardrop	0.692572
Triangle	0.680881
Flash		0.268754
Chevron		0
Egg		0

Excellent! The new metric still shows Fireball and Sphere are most
connected with lightning, but now "orb" is jammed in between them at
position #2. Much like we expected when we put in in the list!

So now we know "orb", "Sphere", "Fireball" are most-linked with
lightning. How much is it linked? Does lightning statistically explain
most Sphere sightings or only a tiny minority?

Let's look at the best predictive models across all the states for
these 3 key UFO types and order them by their R2 value.

Best links between monthly lighting events and monthly UFO sightings of
types Sphere, Fireball and "orb":
State/Type	R2
IN/orb		0.98421267
UT/Fireball	0.91041213
MT/orb		0.88752409
RI/Sphere	0.87024033
WA/orb		0.62927635
SD/Fireball	0.60176630
NE/Fireball	0.59625340
ME/Sphere	0.46841011
IN/Fireball	0.42825421
PA/orb		0.39988382

So it seems UFO's described by observers as "orbs" in Indiana are
"98%" connected with lighting events in the same month.  When there is
more lighting there are more of those type of sightings; when there is
less lightning there are fewer orb sightings.  This says nothing about
any OTHER type of sighting, and we can deduce by the relatively weak
links *on average* it is likely other types of UFO sightings even in
Indiana have no statistical link with lightning strikes.

The table above is the top 10. We see even at the 10th line the link
has rapidly dropped to only 40% of "orb" sightings in Pennsylvania.
IOW for most UFO sightings in most states lightning likely explains
less than 40% of those sightings. It is a "major factor" in some
locations but is a minor factor most places and for most types of UFO sighting.

Finally, we can ask what factor related to each state explains why
some states see bigger links between lighting and e.g. "orb" sightings
are some don't.

Here's the complete table for "Fireball" sightings (the list of "orb"
cases is too small to analyze with technique I'm using here):

Links between monthly lightning strikes and Fireball UFO sightings:
State		R2
UT		 0.91041213
SD		 0.60176630
NE		 0.59625340
IN		 0.42825421
MN		 0.35341019
LA		 0.22022736
MD		 0.18959832
KY		 0.11689561
NJ		 0.11535397
AZ		 0.10069822
WA		 0.08268267
OR		 0.07939861
WI		 0.06073642

Is there something that explains why Utah is at 91% and Wisconsin is
at only .06?

This is where using AI's comes in handy. They can just shuffle through
their toolbox and experience log to figure out an answer to any
off-the-wall question. Sometimes their answer even makes sense!

Although my AI is currently a bit weak in the state-by-state data
available to run its tests, it immediately spits out a table:

Suspect		R2		Beta		(+- 90% CI)
pre12		0.33393964	-0.000598472  0.000484434
pre1		0.32851147	-0.000615761  0.000504573
sdpre		0.29939100	-0.00177829   0.001473

IOW there is only 1 statistically strong suspect. "Pre12" is AI speak
for "December monthly precipitation". The major explanation -- quite
reasonably -- is those states with more rainfall esp in Dec and Jan
("pre1") are those states with weaker links between lighting and
Fireball UFO sightings. Drier states == stronger link.  (The "sdpre"
suspect is the variation e.g. between summer and winter precipitation --
it seems the more variable rainfall is across a state the lower the
connection between lightning and Fireball UFO sightings; ball
lightning seems to like dry climates and dry most of the year).

It seems Fireball UFO's are most likely a product of "dry lightning"
which is apparently relatively common in Utah and much less common in
Wisconsin.  Precipitation only explains about 1/3 of the
state-to-state variation in lighting/Fireball connection -- there are
other factors. But the AI's database presently doesn't include
anything that it otherwise picks up. And "average altitude" is already
in there. It isn't likely to be one of these other factors.


--
Upcoming events:
9 Jul 2021		NOAA billion Dollar Disasters Q2

Complacency Let Covid Erode Taiwan's Only Line of Defense
Bloomberg, 19 May 2021 07:48Z
All the virus had to do was get through the border. Until this week,
Taiwan's Covid-19 containment appeared to be so effective that virtually no
other defenses ...

[Conspiracy!]
From `kooky' conspiracy theory to major US congressional inquiry - UFOs have
finally hit the mainstream
Independent.ie, 19 May 2021 01:52Z
When the US Navy pilot first spotted the strange object hovering in
restricted airspace off the Atlantic coast, he was ...

Bombshell UFO report from US tipped to be 'story of the century'
Daily Express, 19 May 2021 20:00Z
But the existence of top secret locations, most famously the US airbase
commonly known as Area 51 in Nevada, has fuelled ...

NSW has 5000L of "napalm-like" poison to battle mouse plague
ABC News, 20 May 2021 08:22Z
With the plague set to hit Sydney by August the govt is getting set to
import 2000L more of one of the highest toxicity poisons to deal with it.
Mouse plagues normally burn our after 3 months but unusually large
rainfalls in key locations this year have seen this one run 8m.  The
NSW Ag Min has announced a war chest of 5000L of bromadiolon but
warned that's only enough for 10 days at present usage.  Farmers have
been eaten out of house and home and baits and traps have sold out.
The mice have long ago turned to cannibalism to keep going. Farmers
have begun burning hay stockpiled for the next drought to try to
battle the pests.  The govt has approved double-strength baits but env
groups are worried over-use of the poison will kill non-target animals
and possibly affect public health in rural NSW. Rural vets say they've
already seen many cases where pet animals have been badly affected.

Hoarder used 70 bottles of air freshener to hide smell of corpse he lived
with for 15 years, inquest finds
ABC News, 20 May 2021 04:00Z
A man whose mummified remains were found inside a home on Sydney's lower
north shore after 15 years was shot dead during a botched break and enter,
and was only discovered after the homeowner died, a coroner finds.

Which countries are at risk of big COVID outbreaks, and will we even notice?
ABC/The Conversation, 20 May 2021 07:03Z
Could we see more COVID crises like that in India, with cases rapidly
spiking and health systems being overwhelmed? The short answer, sadly, is yes,
writes Michael Head.

'Security risk creator': China says US warship illegally entered its
territory in South China sea
ABC News, 20 May 2021 07:38Z
A US warship illegally entered China's territorial waters in the South China
Sea, China says, the latest salvo in the two nations' dispute over Beijing's
territorial claims in the busy waterway.

Research on Bizarre Rodent Genetics Solves a Mystery - And Then Things Got
Even Stranger
SciTechDaily, 20 May 2021 02:43Z
Open up Scott Roy's Twitter bio and you'll see a simple but revealing
sentence: "The more I learn the more I'm confused." Now the rest of the
scientific world can ...

Ford unveils the F-150 Lightning, its all-electric pickup truck that will
start under $40,000
TechCrunch, 20 May 2021 04:13Z
The Ford F-150, the profitable cornerstone of the U.S. automaker's business,
now has an all-electric sibling. Ford unveiled Wednesday the F-150 Lightning, ...

Race for world's first commercially viable electric plane: The battle for
"Tesla of the skies"
CBS This Morning, 19 May 2021 13:39Z

World's biggest iceberg spotted by satellite after calving from Antarctica
ABC News, 20 May 2021 02:18Z
A giant slab of ice breaks from Antarctica and enters the Weddell Sea,
becoming the largest iceberg currently afloat in the world, the European
Space Agency says.

India records the pandemic's highest known daily death toll for a single country.
The New York Times, 19 May 2021 16:09Z
India recorded 4,529 Covid-19 deaths on Tuesday, the pandemic's highest
single known daily death toll in any country so far, the authorities said on
Wednesday ...

`This is a nightmare': 4th extreme weather event within a year wears
on residents
AccuWeather | Local, National, & Global Weather, 19 May 2021 20:07Z
First two hurricanes, then a deep freeze -- and now a deadly deluge of rainfall.

Tick risk now widespread in Michigan
WDIV ClickOnDetroit, 19 May 2021 12:46Z
Warm weather is returning to Michigan, and so, too, is the risk from ticks.
Experts say that ticks are not just an "up north problem" in Michigan
anymore -- the ...

Google wants to build a useful quantum computer by 2029
The Verge, 19 May 2021 10:44Z
Google is aiming to build a "useful, error-corrected quantum computer" by
the end of the decade, translating to a target of 2029. It says the
technology will be ...

A Ghostly Solution: Strange Property of the Quantum Realm Enables Efficient
Energy Harvesting in Tiny Device
SciTechDaily, 17 May 2021
Scientists at the University of Colorado Boulder have tapped into a
poltergeist-like property of electrons to design devices that can capture
excess heat from their ...

Atlas 5 rocket launches infrared missile detection satellite for US Space Force
Spaceflight Now, 18 May 2021 22:50Z
If you would like to see more articles like this please support our coverage
of the space program by becoming a Spaceflight Now Member. If everyone who ...