Criminology resources

The following are more-or-less random resources relevant to criminology.

They also include, from time-to-time, documents relevant to the "gun debate" in the USA and Australia (this may eventually need a section for itself). Documents both for and against gun controls and relevant pro- and anti- arguments are included.


Keyword search of local Crime documents
A query can consist of one or more keywords in glimpse format (e.g. foo;bar finds all articles with both foo and bar in the same line) and it will return a list of every line in every file in my CRIME files that matches the query.

Potted search of Aussie News & my news morgue for items possibly related to (violent) crime
Can result in quite large output (found 2989 matches in 463 files in late 1997).

Logfile of queries
(Sometimes interesting to know what others want to know or expect to find, above).

Australian Institute of Criminology
See also the stats page, and perhaps particularly the Deaths Caused by Firearms, 1986--1995 and Recorded Multiple Killings 1987 - 28 April 1996 .

Florida State University School of Criminology & Criminal Justice
Comprehensive US-related crime/justice/criminology information. Online books, law links and crime pages. Various special topics include: Juvenile Delinquency and Juvenile Justice; Drug and Alcohol Information; Police Agencies and Resources; Pornography, Obscenity, Censorship & The Communications Decency Act; Community Corrections, Restorative Justice, Prisons and the Death Penalty; etc. Search-able database(s).
[Multi-award-winning site maintained by (Dr) Cecil E. Greek]

Criminology Resources (at AC.UK)
Good resource for UK- (and some European-) oriented crime & justice information. General Resources; Includes links to: Official Publications; Police; Prisons; Associations & Organisations; Electronic Journals.
[Maintained by David Fisher]

The British Journal of Criminology (from Oxford Journals)
The British Journal of Criminology is one of the most influential journals in its field in the English speaking language. It is widely consulted by academics and researchers in criminology, probation and social work, and by professionals concerned with law, criminal justice, and penology.

British Society of Criminology Journal
[Under Construction as of Sep 20, 1997]

CJS: Sociology Resources (from U Alberta)

American Society of Criminology (U Maryland)
See the ASC News and Other Criminal Justice Sites.
[Maintained by Stephen Robinson. Direct ASC questions to cwellford@bss2.umd.edu. Under construction as of Sep 1997]

Northern Illinois University Department of Sociology
See Critical Criminology Division (ASC), American Society of Criminology Mentors Program, Prison Information and Statistics, and Wrongful Murder Convictions. And see the NIU newsletter (special issue: "Critical Criminology: Past. Present. Future?").

Amy Williams Comparative Criminology Homepage (she's at NIU)
See International resources and Other useful sites.

Edmonton Crime Spots Project Home page (U of Alberta)

United Nations Crime and Justice Information Network
This electronic clearing-house represents the culmination of six years of incremental efforts coordinated by the United Nations Crime Prevention and Criminal Justice Branch, Vienna. The goal of the Branch is to act as coordinator and arbiter of this forum for the international exchange and dissemination of information on crime prevention and criminal justice issues.

How Accurate is Crime Data?
Crime reports are provided by criminal justice agencies, victims and offenders. In all three types of reports there are two general limitations which must be considered.

One in 5 US teens victim of violent crime
Using data from government crime reports and academic studies, a 2002 report has found one in five US teens has been the victim of a violent crime.

Preliminary Semiannual Uniform Crime Report, January - June 2002
The violent crime offenses of murder and forcible rape both showed increases in 2002 when compared to 2001 numbers, with murder increasing 2.3 percent and forcible rape, 1.8 percent. However, robbery showed a decrease of 0.4 percent, and aggravated assault declined 2.8 percent.

US sees end of falling crime rates
The number of major crimes in the US increased in 2001 for the first time in a decades, bringing an end to a fall in violence that had resulted in the lowest crime levels in a generation, according to FBI statistics.
[According to the Federal Bureau of Investigation's Uniform Crime Reports, the crime index rate increased slightly in 2001 after falling for the 10 straight years; from 1992 to 2001 the rate fell 26.5% while from 2000 to 2001 it increased 0.9%. According to the BJS National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS), from 2000 to 2001 the violent crime rate declined 10%, reaching the lowest level in NCVS history].

Uniform Crime Report, 2001 (PDF format)
Preliminary report:
According to preliminary statistics released by the FBI, : 140 of the Nation's law enforcement officers were feloniously killed in the line of duty in 2001. This number includes the 71 officers killed in the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks. Another 77 officers died accidentally during year.
The 69 officers not killed in terrorist attacks died in 65 separate events. This was 18 more than died in 2000. 61 of these events have been cleared by arrest or exceptional means.
Sixty officers were killed in 2001 with firearms. Of these 60 officers, 45 were slain with handguns, 11 with rifles, and 4 with shotguns.
At the time they were slain, 39 officers were wearing body armor. Sixteen officers attempted to use their weapons by unsnapping the holsters, drawing the weapons, or performing an action to indicate an attempt to use the weapons but were unable to fire.

US Victim Survey 2001 (1.7M pdf)
Presents 110 tables with detailed data on major variables measured by the National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS). Includes: Demography of victims; Victims and offenders; Geography; The crime event; Victims and the criminal justice system; Series victimization.

US Victim Survey 2002 (280K pdf)

Whitehouse Social Statistics Briefing Room
The number of people under correctional supervision increased 2.3% from 2000 to 2001.
The estimated number of arrests for drug abuse violations rose from 1999 to 2000.
Violent crime rates declined after 1994 as measured by the National Crime Victimization Survey. Victimization rates for males and females are getting closer in recent years.

Historical data for the USA (1900--1999)
[See also Homicide rates from the Vital Statistics (from c1900--present) and Number and Rates of Firearm Mortality United States, 1965-1996. See also Homicide Rates 1910-1944 arguing a link between higher homicide rates and the prohibition years 1920--1932].

US/Canadian state demographics

US crime statistics by state & region, UCR 1994+1995

Firearms Statistics

Firearm Deaths by State, 1996
n 1996 the U.S. firearms death rate was 12.94 per 100,000. Twenty-seven states were at or above this national average rate. Louisiana ranked as the state with the highest firearms death rate (25.37 per 100,000)—nearly twice the national average. Louisiana was followed by Nevada (22.38 per 100,000), Alaska (21.21 per 100,000), Mississippi (20.90 per 100,000), and Alabama (20.05 per 100,000). Louisiana also ranked first for its rate of firearms homicide (15.68 per 100,000). Alaska ranked first for firearms suicide (14.89 per 100,000), and Tennessee ranked highest in the nation for its rate of unintentional firearms death (1.63 per 100,000).
[From the Violence Policy Center]

Firearm Homicide in New Zealand: victims, perpetrators and their weapons 1992-94
In this three-year national survey of gun homicide, most victims were shot by a licensed gun owner with no previous history of mental illness or violent crime.

Firearm Deaths and Firearm Crime After Gun Licensing in Tasmania by Kate Warner
Firearm regulation appears to have been effective in reducing gun suicide and gun crime in Tasmania. The number, rate and proportion of firearm suicides declined in the Guns Act period and continued to decline in 1996 and 1997. The result is that Tasmania no longer had the highest firearm suicide rate in 1996 and 1997.

Most Gun Killers are Licensed Sporting Shooters with No History of Mental Illness or Violent Crime
In the past ten years, 14 mass shootings in Australia and New Zealand left 124 people dead by gunfire. Police files and coroners' reports show that until the shooting occurred, two-thirds of the killers were considered to be law-abiding gun owners.

Australian firearm buy-back
Archive of (Aus government) media releases, statistics, buyback handbook.
According to the final tally, 643.6K weapons were bought back, with $316K compensation paid.

United Nations International Study on Firearm Regulation
Welcome to the website of the United Nations International Study on Firearm Regulation. Information on the methodology of the study is provided below, as are links to documents presented to the fifth and sixth sessions of the Commission on Crime Prevention and Criminal Justice, including the survey instrument. The data of the Survey are also available below. Note that files may be downloaded in various formats, including the Portable Document Format (*.pdf) from Adobe Systems. Please click here to download the Adobe Acrobat viewer.
[The Survey involves analysing criminal cases, illicit traffic in firearms, national regulations relevant to firearms, and seeks to determine which information should be collected on an on-going basis. It's not directly relevant to studies such as Killias 1993 that seek to establish a connection between availability and use of firearms across various countries].

International comparisons
The United States has weaker firearm regulations and higher numbers of deaths involving firearms than all other industrialized--and even most developing--nations, according to a 1997 study by the United Nations. The study surveyed 49 nations on their firearm legislation, manufacture, and trade regulations, as well as on their rates of firearm crime and death.

Uniform Crime Reports [May 5, 1996]
TABLE 1 - CRIME INDEX TRENDS Percent change 1995 over 1994, offences known to the police.

Uniform Crime Reports [May 5, 1996]
TABLE 2 - CRIME INDEX TRENDS BY GEOGRAPHIC REGION

Uniform Crime Reports [May 5, 1996]
TABLE 3 - CRIME INDEX TRENDS January through December, each year over previous year

Uniform Crime Reports [May 5, 1996]
TABLE 4 - OFFENCES KNOWN TO THE POLICE January through December, 1995 over 1994 Cities over 100,000 Population. Major crimes and Crime Index total.

Offences known to police 1994/5
Table showing rates of murder, rape, robbery, assault, burglarly, larceny, MV theft and arson per 100K population for each US city >= 100K population reporting in 1994 and 1995.

1995 Crime in the United States (FBI report, 13 Oct 1996)
PDF file, 7.5 MB.

Final 1994 crime statistics (Nov 19, 1995)
Final 1994 crime statistics released today by FBI Director Louis J. Freeh showed that 14 million Crime Index offenses were reported to law enforcement across the Nation. The 1994 total represents a rate of 5,374 offenses for every 100,000 United States inhabitants. The number of crimes was down 1 percent from 1993, while the crime rate declined 2 percent. The number of violent crimes dropped 3 percent, while the rate of violent crimes dropped 4 percent. In the nine U.S. cities with more than one million population, the decrease in the number of violent crimes was 8 percent. In the 66 largest cities, with populations over 250,000, Crime Index totals dropped 4 percent.

USA crime statistics by city and region (1994 UCR)

USA crime statistics by city and region (1995 UCR)

Violent Crime: National Crime Victimization Survey (Apr 1994)
Summary findings, from the US Department of Justice Statistics.

Numbers of Murders
Numbers of murders for all American cities over 100K population from UCR Report, 1994.

WORST U.S. CRIME CITIES
For cities with populations over 1 mn, the odds of being the victim of murder. Although NYc is cited as being "high" on the list, the top few "cities" c1990 are Washington DC, New Orleans, Richmond VA, and Las Vegas.
[Thanks to Tim Lambert for this one]

Resident Population for Cities With 1994 Population Greater Than 100,000
Source: Population Distribution and Population Estimates Branches US Bureau of the Census.

Crime: state rankings
State-by-state rankings for violent crime, fed & stat prisoners and reported child abuse cases, 1992. [AKA, why do some people cite Vermont and New Hampshire as "typical" American states?].

Philadelphia Homicide Statistics [1994-1995]
Philadelphia seems to be one of the few US cities that maintain crime statistics online.
Send comments and suggestions for new searches and reports to editor@phillynews.com.

Philadelphia Homicide Statistics [1994-1995]
883 homicides broken down by murder weapon.

Personal and Household Crime, 1991
The Bureau of Justice Statistics (BJS) said today that the estimated number of personal and household crimes in the U.S. rose 1.9 percent last year, increasing from 34.4 million in 1990 to 35.1 million in 1991.
[Also see BJS web pages].

What is Killing Canadians?
Causes of Death 1992 (Minister of Industry, Science and Technology, Statistics Canada, Health Statistics Division, Sept. 1994); and, Method of Committing Homicide Offences, Canadian the Provinces/Territories, 1992 (Minister of Industry, Science and Technology, Statistics Canada, Canadian Centre for Justice Statistics, 1992)

Canadian Homicide Trends 1961--1994 compiled by Boris Gimbarzevsky
Until 1977, rifles and shotguns could be purchased in Canada without any controls whatever. Starting in 1977, it was first necessary to obtain a Firearms Acquisition Certificate (FAC) in order to purchase any rifle or shotgun. Data collected for the period 1961--1994 show a significant pattern of increasing rate of rifle+shotgun murders until 1977, and a decline thereafter until c1994 the murder rate using rifles+shotguns approached that for pistols. During the same period all pistols were required to be registered in Canada with stringent carry restrictions. The rate of pistol homicides may thus be considered as a measure of the efficacy of firearm registration. Registration of pistols has been in effect in Canada since the 1930's.

Statistics About Criminal Offenders
[US] Bureau of Justice Statistics.

Statistics About Crime and Victims
[US] Bureau of Justice Statistics.

Criminal Victimization 1996: Changes 1995-96 with Trends 1993-96
The murder rate dropped 10% between 1995 and 1996--the largest decrease in the past 4 years.

Selected UCR figures [1985]
Statistics obtained via http://Justice.uafss.alaska.edu/Documents/Ucrprog.html showing homicide rate averages, medians and standard deviations for US cities and towns, and comparison with New York. Numbers for major crimes for the States of New York and Texas are also presented.

Notes for Ucrprog.html
Figures used in this release are submitted voluntarily by law enforcement agencies throughout the country. Individuals using these tabulations are cautioned against drawing conclusions by making direct comparisons between cities due to the many factors which affect the amount and type of crime from place to place. Some of these factors are listed in the annual Uniform Crime Reports. More valid use can be made of these figures by determining deviations from national averages and through comparisons with averages for cities in similar population groups.

International statistics 1986--1990, homicides

International statistics 1986--1990, committed homicides

REPORTS ON CRIME, PRISONS, AND LAW ENFORCEMENT IN THE U.S. [1991]
The 1991 Survey of Inmates in State Correctional Facilities is a prime source of information about persons held in prisons across the Nation. Through lengthy interviews and detailed questions with a representative sample of State inmates, the survey complements the statistical series that rely on official agency data. The survey data provide a profile of who is in prison and how they got there. The 1991 survey, together with similar surveys conducted in 1974, 1979, and 1986, represents the largest single database on the Nation's prisoners and is an invaluable resource for evaluating the effectiveness of current incarceration policies and practices.

[US] Bureau of Justice Statistics
Crimes and victims. Criminal offenders. Special topics. The Justice System. Crime & Justice from other sources.

Violence Policy Center
The Violence Policy Center is a national non-profit organization working to fight firearms violence through research, education, and advocacy. As a gun control "think tank," the VPC analyzes a wide range of current firearm issues and provides information to policymakers, journalists, public health professionals, grassroots activists, and members of the general public.

Firearm Injury from Crime
From the Dept of Justice, Apr 1996. (Include injuries of law enforcement officers).
[Thanks to Pim Van Meurs for this one].

Firearm Injury from Crime: Firearms, Crime, and Criminal Justice
[US] Bureau of Justice Statistics.

Department of Justice (Victoria) -- Firearm Reform
Certain firearms are now prohibited in Victoria. During the amnesty, (2 July 1996 - 30 Sept 1997) compensation will be paid for semi - automatic centre fire and rim fire rifles, semi - automatic and pump action shotguns. Compensation will be paid whether a shooter is licensed or unlicensed and whether the firearm is registered or not. Cheques will be issued on the spot, no questions asked.

The Australian Firearms Buyback
On May 10th 1996, the Police Ministers from all States and Territories met with the Commonwealth and agreed on new laws for firearm ownership. This involved compensating owners of those firearms which had been made illegal, a process that ended on 30 September 1997. This Internet site provides you with information about the Australian Firearms Buyback and how it was implemented.

FIREARMS INJURIES
During the period 1979-87 there was an average of 689 deaths per year due to firearms in Australia, accounting for 8.7% of all injury deaths. Of these, about 77% were suicides, 15% were homicides, and 6% were unintentional shootings. Firearm deaths are the third most common cause of injury-related deaths in at least one State (NSW).
[from the Public Health Association of Australia].

More guns and younger assailants a combined police and trauma center study . [JAMA, October 1 1997]
From June 1991 to May 1992 and June 1993 to May 1994, the incidence of penetrating trauma increased from 27% to 35% of trauma center admissions (chi2 test; P<.001). During the period from June 1985 to May 1994, assault with a deadly weapon increased by 220% and firearms became the most common assault mechanism (from 32% to 54%; chi2 test; P<.001). Assailants using guns became significantly younger, with the percentage of assailants aged 11 to 20 years increasing from 24% to 47% (chi2 test; P=.001). The ages of assault victims also decreased (P<.003), but were more evenly distributed across age categories.
[See lots more stuff under JAMA search engine (try keyword "firearms")].

State gun safe storage laws and child mortality due to firearms . [JAMA, October 1, 1997]
Laws that make gun owners responsible for storing firearms in a manner that makes them inaccessible to children were in effect for at least 1 year in 12 states from 1990 through 1994. Among children younger than 15 years, unintentional shooting deaths were reduced by 23% (95% confidence interval, 6%-37%) during the years covered by these laws. This estimate was based on within-state comparisons adjusted for national trends in unintentional firearm-related mortality. Gun-related homicide and suicide showed modest declines, but these were not statistically significant.

Firearms -- Violence in Australia
Debate about regulation of firearms in Australia has always provoked intense controversy and generally revolves around issues related to use of guns in violent crime. In particular, supporters of stricter gun control argue that there is clear evidence of a direct relationship between availability of firearms and use in violent incidents and the need to establish a uniform national approach. Opponents within the gun lobby argue that most gun owners don't act illegally and that a tightening of gun laws is unnecessarily inconvenient. They claim that gun related deaths are perpetrated by people who are clearly identified as criminal and/or psychologically disturbed.

Injury by Firearms Australia 1994 by J Harrison, J Moller, S Bordeaux (June 1996)
Key facts:
[Some graphs showing per capita rates across Aussie States, etc].

Annotated Bibliography of some Literature on Firearms
This is an annotated bibliography of papers published in the medical literature related to firearms during 1994-1995. This bibliography is far from complete, but includes several useful papers. Papers are listed in alphabetical order by last name of the first author and by title if there is no author. The comments on each paper are provided by Peter Cummings MD, MPH, an epidemiologist with the Harborview Injury Prevention and Research Center and the University of Washington.

Guns, murder & suicide Bibliography

Guns and Crime: Handgun Victimization, Firearm Self-Defense, and Firearm Theft
Bureau of Justice Statistics Crime Data Brief by Michael R. Rand, BJS Statistician.
In 1992 offenders armed with handguns committed a record 931,000 violent crimes. Handgun crimes accounted for about 13% of all violent crimes. As measured by the National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS), the rate of non-fatal handgun victimizations in 1992--4.5 crimes per 1,000 people age 12 or older--supplanted the record of 4.0 per 1,000 in 1982.
[See also Murders, robberies, and aggravated assaults in which firearms were used, numbers of offenses and rates per 100,000 population, 1973 to 1998].

US gun ownership demographics
Data culled from the aggregate GSS data 1988-1993.

Some recent data on gun ownership, homicide and suicide
Data from studies by Killias, Canadian DoJ, etc.

Deaths Resulting from Firearm- and Motor-Vehicle-Related Injuries -- United States, 1968-1991
Number, crude rates, and ratios of firearm- and motor-vehicle-related deaths; Observed and predicted firearm- and motor-vehicle-related injury Comparison of firearm- and motor-vehicle-related deaths.
[part of The CDC Prevention Guidelines Database]

Youth Suicide Prevention Programs -- Research Findings
Sloan, et al. (1990), compared suicide rates in King County (Seattle), Washington, with that in the Vancouver, British Columbia, metropolitan area, where handgun regulations are considerably more restrictive. The rate of youth suicide from other means (e.g., poisoning and hanging) was similar in both areas, but the rate of suicide by handguns among 15- to 24-year-olds was about 10 times higher in the Seattle area (Table 9). Neither Vancouver nor Seattle, however, substantially restricts access to rifles or shotguns, and in both communities the rates of suicides involving these classes of weapons were similar.
[part of The CDC Prevention Guidelines Database]

HANDGUNS USED IN MORE THAN ONE MILLION VIOLENT CRIMES [DOJ report 1995]
About 1.3 million U.S. residents faced an assailant armed with a firearm during 1993, the Department of Justice announced today. Eighty-six percent of the time (in 1.1 million violent crimes) the weapons were handguns. Seventy percent of the 24,526 murders in 1993 were committed with firearms, of which four out of five were with a handgun. Recent studies indicate that the use of large caliber semi-automatic handguns in homicides has been increasing.
Handguns predominate in firearms crime. More than three-quarters of the 83,000 guns used in crime that ATF traced for law enforcement agencies in 1994 were handguns. Almost 60 percent of the 2 million stolen gun reports in the FBI's National Crime Information Center files are handguns.
More than half of all the handguns manufactured domestically since the turn of the century are 20 years old or less. From 1973 through 1993, more than 40 million handguns were produced in the United States.

Firearms and Violence by Jeffrey A. Roth
Most murders involve firearms, and young minority men are at especially high risk of being murdered with a gun. Innovations in laws, law enforcement, public education, and technology all show promise of reducing gun murders by selectively making firearms less available to persons likely to use them in violence, less accessible in situations where violence is likely to occur, or less lethal. Evaluations are needed to test the effectiveness of these innovations.

Understanding & Preventing Violence by Jeffrey A. Roth
Violence is a serious social problem. In 1990, 23,438 Americans were murdered--a rate of 9.4 for every 100,000 people. In the latest years for which comparative data are available, this rate was nearly double that of Spain, which had the second highest rate in the industrialized world. The murder rate in the United States in 1988 was four times that of Canada.
Violent crime short of murder is also a frequent occurrence in this country. An estimated 2.9 million serious nonfatal violent victimizations--rapes, personal robberies, and aggravated assaults--occurred in 1990, according to the National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS). The rates per 100,000 population for these crimes were also among the world's highest.

Violence in America - Effective Solutions by Edgar A. Suter
It is increasingly common to hear "guns are a virus" or discussion of "the bullet as pathogen." According to Koch's Postulates of Pathogenicity, the criteria used to assess disease-causing potential, any observation of the peaceful use of firearms is sufficient reason to reject the hypothesis that guns or ammunition are pathogens. The half of American homes with guns offer a multitude of such observations. Further still, review of the literature shows that guns and ammunition meet none of Koch's Postulates of Pathogenicity. As appealing as the claim may be to some, guns are not pathogens and crime is not a disease. Crime is a social problem that does not lend itself to analysis or treatment under the medical model.
[Dr Suter goes on to conclude "guns" are a social problem and are best deal with by "the methods of social science research"].

Violence on TV: Aggressive Models in Every Living Room
People can learn undesirable and antisocial forms of behaviour through the same processes that foster the development of social co-operation, sharing, altruism, and efficient problem-solving skills. Violence as portrayed in the mass media, especially on TV, has long been suspected of having such a negative impact on those that consume it.
[Adapted from "Personality Theories" by Hjelle & Ziegler, McGraw-Hill, 1992]

The Portrayal of Violence in the Media: Impacts & Implications for Policy by Melanie Brown
Researchers and professionals have argued for decades about whether or not the portrayal of violence in the various media causes violence in society. Laboratory experiments, field research and correlational studies have all been used as investigative tools. Some studies have suggested that there is a direct causal relationship between violence in entertainment and violent behaviour, and others have concluded that there is no association whatsoever. Most studies have shown that there is some sort of relationship or association. [From AIC]

Perceptions of the Criminal Justice System: Television Imagery and Public Knowledge in the United States by Connie L. McNeely
Research has suggested that a majority of people in the United States receive much of their impressions and knowledge of the criminal justice system through the media, especially through entertainment television viewing. Drawing on this work, a programmatic research approach based on three primary strategies in selected substantive areas is developed for in depth inquiry and study of what people actually know, or think they know, about the criminal justice system.

NEWS MEDIA PROMOTES BOGUS CCW STUDY by J. Neil Schulman
The Associated Press wire story from March 13, 1995, was titled, "Relaxed Gun Laws Mean More Deaths." This is a typical media story intended to make you think that the more guns you have, the more endangered you are. It has already been the basis for the Los Angeles Times to editorialize against reforming California's laws which currently make it impossible for most Californians to carry firearms for self- protection without threat of arrest and prosecution under Penal Code Section 12025.

Mike's CCW Cross-Reference Grid (related to US-centric "Carry Concealed Weapons" sub-topic)
Restrictions are almost always imposed upon CCW holders. The following is a list of places many states will not permit you to carry. Also, you may be confronted with local ordinances and individual business restrictions.
[Thanks to Tim Lambert for this one]

The Value of Civilian Arms Possession As Deterrent To Crime Or Defense Against Crime
The crime reductive value of civilian firearms ownership is a central issue in the "gun control" controversy. Sixty five years of vitriolic debate have amply proven the wisdom of a leading early 20th Century opponent of gun ownership, New York City Chief Magistrate William McAdoo in predicting that
"We shall make no progress in removing this national menace until this basic fact as to the ineffectiveness of arming citizens is well and thoroughly understood by the people who foolishly buy pistols and arm themselves."
[from AMERICAN J OF CRIM LAW (1991)].

Do Concealed Handgun Laws Save Lives? by John R. Lott, Jr. (March 26, 1998)
States from Michigan to Nebraska to California, as well as the federal government, are considering new rules on letting law-abiding citizens carry guns. Does allowing citizens to carry concealed handguns deter violent crimes?
Using the FBI's crime-rate data for all 3,054 U.S. counties by year from 1977 to 1992, I co-authored a study in the January 1997 Journal of Legal Studies. We found that concealed handguns deter violent crimes and produce no significant increase in accidental handgun deaths.

Carrying Concealed Guns is Not the Solution by Douglas Weil, Sc.D. (March 26, 1998)
On Sept. 10, 1997, five men licensed to carry concealed handguns got into a fight outside a Pittsburgh saloon after exchanging "hostile looks." All of the men fired their weapons and ended up in the hospital.
The gun lobby attempts to justify this dangerous political agenda by citing research conducted by Dr. John Lott. Lott's study concludes that making it easier for citizens to carry concealed weapons reduces violent crime rates.
In fact, in a nationally-televised symposium at which Lott's work was critiqued, Dr. Daniel Nagin of Carnegie Mellon University, Dr. Daniel Black of the University of Kentucky, and Dr. Jens Ludwig of Georgetown University agreed that Lott's study is so flawed that "nothing can be learned of it" and that it "cannot be used responsibly to formulate policy." Since then, no credible evidence has been produced to rebut the conclusions of Black, Nagin and Ludwig, or other researchers who have identified additional flaws with Lott's work.

Cease Fire [1996]!
Myths about guns and safety, and crime and children in the US, from the Children's Defense Fund.

Gun Acquisition and Possession in Selected Juvenile Samples (1992) by Joseph F. Sheley & James D. Wright
This Research in Brief summarizes the results of a study concerning the number and types of firearms juveniles possess as well as where, how, and why juveniles acquire and carry firearms. The findings derive from responses to surveys completed by selected samples of male inmates (mostly from urban areas) in juvenile correctional facilities in California, New Jersey, Louisiana, and Illinois and male students in 10 inner-city public high schools near the correctional institutions surveyed.

Crime wave
The US is a terribly violent country, but there's no explosion in crime. Crime rate flat, incarceration soars. Victims mainly downscale and nonwhite. Pandemic bastardry no explanation.
[from Left Business Observer, 1994]

Archive of Gun Control postings
International comparisons. Canada's 1978 gun control laws. NSW's introduction of gun control in 1920. Japanese homicide and suicide. Guns used for defence...
[from Tim Lambert at UNSW Com Sci & Eng ]

The can.talk.guns FAQ List by Skeeter Abell-Smith
My aim is to keep this FAQ (Frequently Asked Questions) list as short as possible while covering a lot of areas quickly and pointing people toward more information. Instead of providing exhaustive detail, I have listed references and "recommended reading". The trade-off between precision and brevity will be an ongoing struggle.

GUN CONTROL: A REALISTIC ASSESSMENT by Don B. Kates Jr.
My purpose in this paper is to summarise the current data on all major aspects of the gun controversy. I shall supplement and update the NIJ Evaluation in light of numerous credible studies that have appeared since the mid-1970s. Predictably, this data has emerged from analyses approaching gun ownership as a social phenomenon to be studied rather than as a problem to be exorcised by polemics thinly disguised as academic discourse.

Gary Kleck, Ph.D
Kleck's home page at FSU. Although Gary is sometimes touted to be a specialist in criminology, his PhD from University of Illinois at Urbana (1979) is in Sociology. His home page describes his professional services as including:
Editorial Consultant, American Sociological Review, American Journal of Sociology, Social Forces, Social Problems, Law and Society Review, Social Science Research, Criminology, Journal of Quantitative Criminology, Journal of Criminal Justice, Violence and Victims, Journal of the American Medical Association.

Prof Leslie Kennedy
Professor Kennedy is the Coordinator of the Center for Criminological Research at the University of Alberta. His research interests are in criminal victimisation, and community attitudes towards crime and safety, and he has published extensively in these areas. He has been involved in research on Canadian and American homicide trends, examining these data for clues concerning the social and familial roots of murder.

Frank R. Scarpitti
Frank Scarpitti teaches courses on social problems and criminology. He has conducted research in the areas of mental health treatment, juvenile delinquency, corrections, organized crime, and female criminality. Currently, he works in the area of drug treatment program evaluation. He has authored or co-authored a number of books and articles, including Social Problems, Poisoning for Profit, Group Interaction as Therapy, Women, Crime and Justice, and Drugs and the Youth Culture. He received the American Psychiatric Association's Hofheimer Prize for Research in 1967, served as President of the American Society of Criminology in 1981, and was named the recipient of the University of Delaware's Francis Alison Award in 1995.

POINT BLANK by Gary Kleck
This paper of a summary of my book, Point Blank: Guns and Violence in America, which in turn summarises the literature on guns, violence and gun control, as well as reporting new research. The purpose of the paper is to outline the main findings and conclusions, without systematically establishing the empirical basis for each conclusion. These can be found in the book itself. And since the book has about 570 references, it is not practical to cite supporting materials for each assertion. Only studies summarised in the tables are contained in the References. Instead, I have simply indicated the chapter of the book where interested readers may find the full set of supporting citations, empirical evidence, and detailed argumentation.

Why are the Black and Hispanic homicide rates so high in Seattle?
Argument against Sloan JH, Kellermann AL, Reay DT, et al. "Handgun Regulations, Crime, Assaults, and Homicide: A Tale of Two Cities." N Engl J Med 1988; 319: 1256-62.
Sloan, Kellermann, and their co-authors attempted to prove that Canada's gun laws caused low rates of violence. In their study of Vancouver, the authors failed to compare homicide rates before and after the law. As Blackman noted, they had ignored or overlooked that Vancouver had 26% more homicides after the Canadian gun ban, an observation that should warrant scientific exploration and generate a healthy skepticism of the authors' foregone conclusions.
[Contains nice graphs of international comparisons of homicide and suicide].

Serious Flaws in Kellerman, et al (1993) NEJM
A NEJM article by Kellerman et al, that found that gun ownership was associated with an increased risk of homicide in the home, has attracted much criticism for its methodology. Here is some from Henry E. Schaffer.

The Kansas City Gun Experiment (1994)
Gun crime has been increasing rapidly throughout the Nation, especially in inner-city areas. To learn whether vigorous enforcement of existing gun laws could reduce gun crime, the National Institute of Justice (NIJ) sponsored an evaluation of the Kansas City, Missouri, Police Department's "Weed and Seed" program. The evaluation found that the program's success in getting more guns off the street in one violent Kansas City neighborhood reduced gun crimes there by almost 50 percent during a 6-month period. The data indicate that more than two gun crimes were prevented for every gun seized.

THE LONG LIST OF "GUN-CONTROL" MYTHS
[talk.politics.guns' Official Pro-Gun FAQ (fully indexed, w/glossary)].

Gun Control Debate
Yahoo's web page. Includes links to current news stories and other web resources.

SunSpot: Crime & Punishment
From the Baltimore Sun's "Maryland's Online Community".
This section covers Baltimore's ongoing struggle to reform the court system and to decrease crime with more effective policing; stories on gun legislation at the local and national levels; and coverage of the relationship between Baltimore's high murder rate and the drug trade.

Gun Contol
One of The New American's (yet another Right Wing Republican mouthpiece) "Issues in Focus". Included here for light relief.
Exercising the Right - December 9, 1999 A regular department of THE NEW AMERICAN, Exercising the Right features real-life stories of American citizens who defended the lives and property of their family with the use of a firearm.
Global Gun Grab - November 22, 1999 It's open season on the right to keep and bear arms as UN globocrats gear up for international gun controls.
Propagandizing the Police - November 8, 1999 Leftist "watchdogs" posing as experts on extremism are advising police agencies in "preemptive" law enforcement. The resulting dragnet will increasingly target law-abiding gun owners, pro-lifers, homeschoolers, and other foes of the total state.

Gun Control (AKA the New York Time's Issues in Depth: "America Under the Gun")
Relying on Bush, Gun Makers End Talks
By FOX BUTTERFIELD
May 4, 2000. Faced with lawsuits by 31 cities and counties, the nation's gun companies have broken off settlement negotiations, deciding to rely on their chances that state judges will prove sympathetic or that victory in November will go to George W. Bush.
Gun Makers See Betrayal in a Decision by Smith & Wesson
By LESLIE WAYNE and FOX BUTTERFIELD
March 18, 2000. Smith & Wesson's decision to adopt gun safety measures in order to settle lawsuits brought by state and federal agencies has set off criticism within the gun industry and a debate among handgun control advocates.

GUN AVAILABILITY AND VIOLENT CRIME: RESEARCH EVIDENCE
A Note by the Crime and Criminal Justice Unit, Research and Statistics Directorate of the Home Office.
This Annex considers research done to see how far gun availability is linked to the level and nature of violent crime. It starts with some points about the problem of measuring gun availability. It then sketches out some of the main arguments put forward against a gun-violence relationship as a framework in which to present some recent evidence which bears on the debate.
[Refers to work by Cook, 1991; 1983; Killias, 1993; Kleck, 1991; Wright et al., 1983; and Zimring and Hawkins, 1987].

Studies on Crime and Crime Prevention
Studies on Crime and Crime Prevention is a peer-reviewed journal addressed to criminologists, sociologists and other scientists conducting research in the field of crime and crime prevention and to other interested readers. It is published for the Swedish National Council for Crime Prevention, Brottsförebyggande Rådet (BRÅ, Stockholm).

MEASURES TO REGULATE FIREARMS (Report of the Secretary-General) COMMISSION ON CRIME PREVENTION AND CRIMINAL JUSTICE, May 1996
Statistics on firearm crime from 25 UN members.

United Nations Surveys of Crime Trends and Operations of Criminal Justice Systems

Counseling to Prevent Youth Violence
Chapter 59 of the Guide to Clinical Preventive Services, a thoroughly updated and expanded version of the 1989 landmark report of the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF).
Homicide is the 10th leading cause of death in the U.S., and because of the young age of its victims is a leading cause of years of potential life lost. More than 25,000 Americans (10.0/100,000 population) were murdered in 1992. The age-adjusted homicide rate increased 25% between 1985 and 1991; a decrease of 3.7% occurred between 1991 and 1992. In the 1991 National Crime Victimization Survey, the rate of aggravated (i.e., involving a weapon) assault was 780/100,000 persons over 12 years of age, while the rate for all non-fatal crimes of violence (including attempted and completed rape, robbery, and assault) was 3,130/100,000. In 1 year, aggravated assaults alone accounted for 355,000 hospitalisations, 4 million lost work-days, and $638 million in medical costs.

FIREARMS FALLACIES
Selected statistics from the NATIONAL FIREARMS ASSOCIATION in Canada. E.g. a 1992 survey sponsored by the UN reported that 26% of Canadians, over 7,000,000 people, own firearms. [c.f. a reported 47% of American adults own at least 1 firearm].

Taking Aim at Gun Control
Heartland Policy Study by Daniel D. Polsby and Dennis Brennen, October 30, 1995.
In the twenty-year period between 1973 and 1992, the number of privately owned firearms in the United States increased 73 percent--from 122 million to nearly 222 million. Handgun ownership increased by 110 percent, from 37 million to 78 million. In 1994, the latest year for which data are available, there were 231 million firearms in private hands in the U.S., 82 million of them handguns.

Bureau of Justice Statistics Publications Catalog, 1996

Firearm Injury from Crime Firearms, crime, and criminal justice (USDJ, April 1996)
Firearm-related crime and resulting injury is a relatively rare event. In 1994 the BJS National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS) found that 29% of the victims of non-fatal violent crime, excluding simple assault, faced an offender armed with a gun. According to the 1992 National Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care Survey, about 0.3% of all injury visits to emergency departments (3 of every 1,000 visits) were caused by firearms. This estimate includes all causes of firearm injury and may also include visits for patients seeking follow-up care and patients who died at the hospital.

VIOLENT OFFENDERS INCREASINGLY LIKELY TO BE ARMED (press release, Feb 1994)
Violent offenders are increasingly likely to be armed, the Bureau of Justice Statistics (BJS) said today. While the overall violent crime rate decreased during the last decade, the rate of offences committed with pistols and revolvers rose from 9.2 percent in 1979 to 12.7 percent in 1992.

Weapons Offences and Offenders: Firearms, crime, and criminal justice (selected findings, USDJ 1995)
The number of Federal weapons offences investigated and prosecuted has increased at least 4-fold since 1980. Weapons offenders are making up an increasing proportion of admissions to State and Federal prisons. Although many more offenders are admitted to Federal prison for drug offences than for weapons offences, from 1985 to 1992 the rate of increase in admissions of weapons offenders was 4 times greater than the rate of increase of drug offenders. Weapons charges as an addition to other charges are more common at the Federal level than the State level.

Federal Firearms-Related Offenses Crime Data Brief [1993]
From 1982 to 1992 the number of Federal defendants sentenced to prison with a weapons offense as their most serious crime increased 175%, from 1,000 to 2,755. However, even larger numbers of Federal offenders were involved with firearms. Considering all Federal sentences, firearms were involved in the crimes of 6,987 offenders, a sixth of those sentenced under guidelines in the 12 months ending September 30, 1993.

Violent Offenders in State Prison: Sentences and Time Served--State Inmates, 1992-94 [DOJ study]
In partnership with State departments of corrections, the Bureau of Justice Statistics (BJS) collected information on sentences and time served by violent offenders in State prison. For 1992, 1993, and 1994, 49 States and the District of Columbia provided information on violent offenders who were admitted to or released from prison.

Violent Prisoners [DOJ statement, 1986]
An estimated one out of six state prisoners serving time during 1986 for a violent crime had committed the offence against a minor, the Bureau of Justice Statistics announced today. The Bureau, a component of the Office of Justice Programs, said a survey also revealed that 41 percent of the violent offenders had a prior relationship with the victim as an acquaintance, an intimate or a relative and 10 percent had committed the offence against a family member.

FELONY DEFENDANTS IN LARGE URBAN COUNTIES, 1988
This report describes the processing of cases for persons arrested for a felony in the nation's 75 largest counties during February 1988. Numerical tables present data on the pretrial, adjudication, and sentencing phases of the criminal justice process.
[summary of 1988 DOJ report]

TRACKING OFFENDERS [DOJ report, 1988]
Felony case processing data from eight states revealed that of the almost 600,000 alleged felons whose cases were disposed of during 1988, 81 percent were prosecuted, 59 percent were convicted and 39 percent were sentenced to a jail or prison term, according to a Bureau of Justice Statistics study released today. The findings are based on criminal case information the states voluntarily send to the Bureau, which is a U.S. Department of Justice agency in the Office of Justice Programs.

Felony Defendants in Large Urban Counties, 1992
A majority (60%) of felony defendants charged as adults in the 75 largest counties were under age 30. A fifth were under age 21, including about a third of murder (35%) and robbery (31%) defendants. Defendants whose most serious arrest charge was a driving-related offense (21%) were the most likely to be age 40 or older.

Felony Sentences in the United States, 1992
In 1992 State courts convicted nearly 900,000 adults of a felony. Forty-four percent of convicted felons were sentenced to a State prison, and 26% were sentenced to a local jail (usually for a year or less). The remaining 30% were sentenced to straight probation with no jail or prison time to serve. These findings come from a survey that is done every 2 years and that provides the only detailed description of the sentences felons receive in State courts nationwide.

Pretrial Release of Felony Defendants, 1992
An estimated 63% of the defendants who had State felony charges filed against them in the Nation's 75 most populous counties during May 1992 were released by the court prior to the disposition of their case. About a third of these released defendants were either rearrested for a new offense, failed to appear in court as scheduled, or committed some other violation that resulted in the revocation of their pretrial release. Of the 25% of released defendants who had a bench warrant issued for their arrest because they did not appear in court as scheduled, about a third, representing 8% of all released defendants, were still fugitives after 1 year.

Capital Punishment 1993
Ten [US] States executed 38 prisoners during 1993. The number of persons executed was seven more than in 1992 and was the largest annual number since the U.S. Supreme Court reinstated capital punishment in 1976. The prisoners executed during 1993 had been under sentence of death an average of 9 years and 5 months, about 1 month less than the average for inmates executed the previous year.
[From the US Department of Justice Office of Justice Programs and Bureau of Justice Statistics, December 1994].

Carjacking: National Crime Victimization Survey (1994)
Carjacking is a type of robbery -- the theft or attempted theft of a motor vehicle by force or threat of force. Between 1987 and 1992, carjackings accounted for 2% of the 1.9 million vehicle thefts per year that occurred in the US. An average of 35,000 completed and attempted carjackings pa took place between 1987 and 1992. In 52% of the carjackings the offender succeeded in stealing the victim's motor vehicle. Most carjacking victims escaped without injury. Victims were injured in 24% of the completed carjackings and 18% of attempted carjackings.

Spouse Murder Defendants in Large Urban Counties (1995)
In 1988 the justice system in the Nation's 75 largest counties disposed of an estimated 540 spouse murder cases. Husbands charged with killing their wife outnumbered wives charged with killing their husband. Of the 540, 318--or 59%--were husband defendants and 222--or 41%--were wife defendants.

Spousal Abuse Rates
The data from the US National Crime Survey (NCS) states that 84% of the victims of "intimate" violence were female. ("Highlights from 20 years of Surveying Crime Victims", NCJ-144525.) It also puts the occurrence of this violent crime (from "intimates only") at 5.4 female victims per 1000 women per year - this is all crimes, some of which did not involve injury. For comparison, the rate for "Accidental injury, all circumstances" is given as 220 per 1000 adults per year - a figure 40 times higher.

Drunk Driving (1992)
More than half the persons in local jails charged with the offense of driving while intoxicated with alcohol (DWI) in 1989 had prior sentences to incarceration for DWI offenses. About 1 in 6 persons jailed for DWI had served at least three prior sentences in jail or prison for drunk driving.

Incoming material
A collection of odds & ends from various places. Eventually these will make their way into this list. In the meantime they do appear in the index for the glimpse keyword search (above).


Kym Horsell /
Kym@KymHorsell.COM

ADVISORY: Email to these sites is filtered. Unsolicited email may be automajically re-directed to the relevant postmaster.

Date created: Thu Feb 5 17:55:05 2004

Date last modified: Sun Oct 26 14:50:05 2003